A group photo where Rachel is sat around a table with artists Ali Saied Ashour, Amna Hussein, Hosaam Khdair and Mahmoud Abu Daghash. They are working outside in the sun and are all looking directly into the camera.
Photo by Gadsden-Hayton

Unlimited International Case Study 2019: Rachel Gadsden – It was Paradise

Unlimited is an arts commissioning programme that aims to embed exceptional work by disabled artists within the UK and international cultural sectors, reach new audiences, and shift perceptions of disabled people. Shape Arts and Artsadmin deliver it in partnership, with funding from Arts Council England, Arts Council of Wales, British Council and Spirit of 2012.

In 2016 an Arts Council England’s Ambitions of Excellence award, match funded by the British Council, enabled Unlimited to extend global influence principally through co-commissions with non-UK based disabled artists. These case studies extend the learning from this work. 

What happened? 

Unlimited commissioned acclaimed British visual and performance artist, Rachel Gadsden, to undertake a research and development (R&D) trip to the occupied Palestinian territories (oPt) in April 2017 to work with disabled Palestinian visual artists.  Over a fortnight in the West Bank and East Jerusalem Gadsden organised and led art workshops and exchanges with lead Palestinian artist, Ali Saeid Ashour, and emerging Palestinian artists Amna Hussein, Mahmoud Abu Daghash, Hossam Khdair and film-maker, Isra Odeh. None of the Palestinian artists had previously had any formal art training and from this perspective Gadsden worked with them as both mentor and collaborator.  

Gadsden and the Palestinian artists also worked closely with 15 women from the Jerusalem Bereaved Women’s Group, which was established to support women who have endured mental health trauma caused by the loss of immediate family members either killed by Israeli forces or civilians, or detained in Israeli prisons.   

This collective of British and Palestinian artists centred their work, inspiration and ethos of “cultivating hope” around words from a poem called ‘Under Siege’ by Palestine’s national poet, Mahmoud Darwish: 

Here on the slopes of hills, facing the dusk and the cannon of time.
Close to the gardens of broken shadows,
We do what prisoners do,
And what the jobless do:
We cultivate hope. 

The title of their project, It was Paradise, is adapted from this poem. 

Gadsden states that the aim of the group was “to develop a visual language to express global concerns about migration, the lingering flight of refugees, disabled and bereaved people” through “the creation of visceral visual artwork and digital films” – and in doing so, ‘to cultivate hope’ in the artists themselves, their immediate communities, and in wider audiences. 

Following this first R&D phase, Gadsden and her Palestinian counterparts received a generous International Unlimited Award to develop the project further. This largely comprised an artistic residency over two weeks in the West Bank with the artists in March 2018.  

The initial R&D leg of Gadsden’s commission gave her the opportunity to gain an essential insight into the complex and difficult local environment caused by Israel’s military occupation, and to develop key contacts that would prove fundamental for the duration of the project and its success. 

The funding for It was Paradise in 2017 and 2018 provided pivotal opportunities for Gadsden, Ashour and the emerging Palestinian artists to gel, get to know one another, exchange ideas, experiences and techniques, and plan their collective artistic output during the residencies. It enabled the collaborative to produce scores of individual artworks and several large collaborative canvases. This time was also used to capture material that film-maker, Isra Odeh, would have available to produce three short films, each focusing on different creative strands of It was Paradise. 

Gadsden has utilised her strong network of arts contacts in the UK and Middle East to get the artwork and talent that brought It was Paradise to life the exposure and recognition it deserves in galleries, exhibitions and spaces in the UK, Jordan and Palestine.  

The project’s work with the Jerusalem Bereaved Women’s Group received a public platform in September 2017 at the recently opened Palestine Museum in Bir Zeit, outside of Ramallah, as part of its inaugural exhibition, “Jerusalem Lives”.  

Exhibitions of artwork from It was Paradise have also been held at the following: 

  • Norman Plaistow Gallery, Wimbledon, London, UK (October 2017) 
  • The Capitol Theatre, Horsham, Sussex UK (June 2018)
  • Milton Keynes Islamic Art and Heritage Festival (June 2018), which included two embroidery panels commissioned by the Festival and created by It was Paradise artist, Amna Hussein
  • Liverpool Arab Arts Festival 2018, in collaboration with Open Eye Gallery, Liverpool, UK (July 2018)
  • ‘Narratives of Displacement’ exhibition, Amman, Jordan (August 2018) – Gadsden was able to bring collaborator, Amna Hussein, to participate 
  • Unlimited Festival Southbank Centre (September 2018) – Gadsden was able to bring collaborator, Ali Saied Ashour, to participate 
  • DaDaFest International 2018, Liverpool, UK, as part of Gadsden’s commission from the Festival of her recent work in the wider Middle East (December 2018) 
  • Alrowwad Refugee Camp Art and Cultural Centre, Bethlehem, Palestine (specific date TBC but scheduled for March 2019)

In addition, the project’s three films shot and edited by Odeh were screened at the 2018 Palestinian International Young Filmmakers Short Film Festival. 

What worked well/what was learnt? 

Gadsden notes that the level and volume of artwork produced, engagement achieved, and the public interest in the work and the collaboration behind It was Paradise “has been far greater and more substantial than was initially anticipated and expected.” 

For the Palestinian artists involved, the opportunity has been invaluable in a number of ways, not least providing a chance to work with a renowned international artist and collaborate with other Palestinian artists, breaking the isolation disabled artists experience in Palestine. 

Amna Hussein said: “Due to the social and political circumstances in the West Bank, the reality is that many [of us] live isolated lives. I have found it incredibly empowering to reach beyond these circumstances. This project gives us the chance to exchange our cultural identity with others. Through visual art I knew I would be able to express my ideology and to share my cultural identify, both as a disabled person, but also as a Palestinian women living under occupation to a far larger audience.” 

For Ashour and Abu Daghash, the project has led directly to recognition and commissions locally. Ashour also sold art pieces at the Unlimited Festival in September 2018 and was overcome by the interest in his work and story. Additionally, Hussein and Ashour have been able to travel internationally as part of their involvement in It was Paradise, which has also been instrumental in their artistic development, networking, and in breaking the isolation they struggle with. 

Locally, the awareness and recognition that Ashour, Hussein, Abu Daghask, Khdair and Odeh have received through local media has also raised awareness of the talents and abilities that disabled members of the community possess, and of the individual and collective value of recognising these in society. 

Caroline Khalaf, Deputy Director of the British Council in Palestine, which was a local partner, says: “Disabled people in general in Palestine are marginalised and projects like this give disabled artist and people hope, inspiration and opportunity. We need to do more of this kind of collaboration with the UK as it is a global leader in the area of disability. The exposure and interaction with UK artists gives Palestinians a sense of worth in being part of a collaboration which showcases their art productions.” 

Mira Koussa, Business Development Assistant at the British Council, adds that opportunities like this collaborative provide disabled Palestinians – artists and non-artists – with an important source of confidence in asserting their identity and contributions they can make to society. 

In the UK, Gadsden added that the response to, and exposure of, their creative output at the various exhibitions has been phenomenal. 

“People want to hear the Palestinian voices and experience them. Audiences in the UK said they never hear this side of the story – just the Israeli side – and so It was Paradise has generated awareness, and audiences here have found it very engaging. That has been an incredible side of the whole experience.” 

She says that one of the biggest issues she has faced, however, has been in managing the expectations of her Palestinian collaborators.  

“It’s been an amazing experience for them but it’s not a sustained project,” says Gadsden. “There is [an understandable] naivety there and the hope that it will continue and grow, but the funding model doesn’t allow for that, and it’s hard to leave them with that realisation. They are left asking ‘What’s next?’ and the specific momentum of the project ends there, and that’s difficult.” 

What can others take from this? 

Collaborative projects with artists in the oPt will, by the nature of the context, be riddled with logistical and societal issues and challenges. But this should infuse rather than deter would-be collaborators. 

Movement restrictions – both locally and internationally – can have a profound impact on plans, ambitions and outcomes. Local movement restrictions imposed by Israel make travel within the West Bank (not to mention between Gaza, the West Bank and East Jerusalem, which is virtually impossible) extremely challenging and time-consuming. And as Ashour, Hussein and Gadsden experienced, getting visas for Palestinian artists to collaborate in the UK was often proved frustrating and disappointing. 

Despite these considerable challenges, the need for such international collaborative artistic projects is huge, and the potential benefits to artists in the UK and in the oPt – and to audiences in the respective locations – is enormous. 

Gadsden and her Palestinian collaborators have succeeded through It was Paradise in showing that “cultivating hope” through such a project is profoundly worthwhile. 

Caroline Khalaf at the British Council adds, “This is worthy project which needs to find a way to sustain the momentum it is building – not just in Palestine but in MENA region.”

 

Links and Contacts

Unlimited
Shape Arts
Artsadmin
British Council in Occupied Palestinian Territories
Rachel Gadsden
Mahmoud Darwish
The Palestine Museum

 

 Other Case Studies Available 

Baluji Shrivastav – Antardrishti – Inner Vision

Richard Butchins – The Voice of the Unicorn
Kaite O’Reilly – And Suddenly I Disappear: The Singapore ‘d’ Monologues 
Unlimited at IETM
International Collaborations
Access to the World – Unlimited International Travel 
Nama Āto: Japanese Outsider Art Exhibition
International Placements
Unfixed

 

PDFs

Rachel Gadsden – It Was Paradise
Rachel Gadsdaen – It Was Paradise (easy read)